This Christmas season, we had a little bit of fun. The four of us (Steve, Marisa, Russell, and Jerry) sat down and crafted our ranking of 25 holiday tunes. We took the average score of each song and came up with the FSN Top 25.

Now, you can find lists of the best Christmas music everywhere on the Internet. We wanted to be a little unique, so we filled our list with a few overlooked gems. You might notice that our list is missing plenty of absolute classics: Silent Night, White Christmas, Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas, Rockin’ Around the Christmas Tree. We did this because—

Jerry: Hey, wait a minute! Why isn’t White Christmas on our list? This is the all-time greatest Christmas song. I have fond memories of watching the film with my mom.

As we were saying, we did this because we wanted to give some love to songs that don’t usually make these lists. If we left out your favorite, we did so because it’s a bonafide classic that was deemed to good for our list.

So here we go. Enjoy our list, feel free to tell us how vehemently you disagree, and have a holly, jolly Christmas this year.

25. You’re a Mean One, Mr. Grinch

24. Here Comes Santa Claus

23. Christmas in the Hollis

22. Grandma Got Run Over By a Reindeer

Marisa: No.
Steve: lol
Jerry: I can’t stand this song.
Russell: Aww you guys are no fun. I almost gave this song my #1 vote! It puts a smile on my face every time I hear it. 

21. Santa Baby

Russell: Gross.
Steve: Yeah, she’s really into Santa.

20. Put a Little Love in Your Heart

19. Little Drummer Boy

Russell: I play the drums, so this has always been a favorite of mine. This is my #1.
Marisa: I’ve always thought it was too slow, but I bet I’d love it if I played the drums, too.

18. Holly Jolly Christmas

17. Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)

Jerry: I love this song. My #1 pick.

16. Last Christmas

15. Deck the Halls

14. Let It Snow

13. Christmas Don’t Be Late

Marisa: This song is cute.
Steve: Yes it is.
Marisa: It makes me think of my childhood, running around the house with my brother and sister.
Jerry: That makes sense. There’s no nostalgia for me with this one. It’s always sounded kinda weird.
Russell: I’m on Team Jerry. How can you guys understand what the chipmunks are saying? It’s impossible.

12. All I Want for Christmas Is You

Marisa: My #1 pick! I LOVE Mariah Carey.
Russell: This was my #25 pick. But to be fair, I love all Christmas music and would never skip this song if it came on.

11. Frosty the Snowman

10. Jingle Bell Rock

9. Happy Christmas

8. The Christmas Song 

7. Santa Claus is Comin’ to Town

6. It’s the Most Wonderful Time of the Year

5. Christmas Canon Rock

4. Baby It’s Cold Outside

3. Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer

2. Jingle Bells

1. Wonderful Christmas Time

Steve: #1 pick for me. Such a happy little tune.
Rusell: Top 5 for me.
Jerry: Ditto.
Marisa: Top 8 for me.
Steve: Sweet. This is a good #1. Well done, team. I’m glad no relationships were destroyed by this list.